How often have you gone to see a patient and she or her family tell you, “I heard I failed the video swallow study”?

There is something to this poor word choice and at times, I notice it is an epidemic slowly spreading and catching fire.

I find myself educating, educating, educating, non stop. I often debunk the words “pass/fail” by stating:  “This is not a test.” If you think about it: No one fails physical therapy. No one fails occupational therapy. No one fails an MRI or Ultrasound.

There’s somehow a huge gap between SLPs as clinicians who only “test” swallowing and clinicians who treat swallowing. I find it helpful to soften the storm before it gets out of control and say to the patient, “When I come to see you it is not to see if you are failing. No one fails in my therapy. I am coming to work with you so you can achieve your goals.” Maybe it just makes me feel better as a therapist, but it seems to be working.

Anyone have any different experiences or suggestions?


Next articleCool, oral gratification!
Dysphagia Café’s mission is to be a quality, consistent, reliable and easily accessible resource community for every dysphagia clinician worldwide. This is achieved by generating and promoting original evidence based content by global leaders in dysphagia research and practice.


  1. I hear that term frequently from the nurses or the PCA’s I work with. Common dialogue:

    RN: So did they pass or fail?
    Me: Well there are somethings that we need to change to their diet and some strategies to be put in place.
    RN: So they passed?

    • I will try to educate in a nice way on how those terms can create some confusion, as passing/failing is not well defined. I may lead with a joke, “No one ever ever fails my swallow eval” : ) One MD may have the idea that passing is not aspiration on a video swallow study, while someone else may define it as being on a regular diet. The best straightforward and simple response I can think of is: “The patient is safe for…” or “The patient is unsafe for…” It is the small victories that will hopefully lead to change.